Latest Posts

Stay in Touch With Us

Got a story worth telling? Send it our way. We read every tip that lands in our inbox.

Livebriefs

  /  All News   /  Poll: Republicans in early 2028 primary states back Israel, not its critics

Poll: Republicans in early 2028 primary states back Israel, not its critics

  

Republican voters in four early 2028 primary states have favorable views of Israel by wide margins and have negative opinions of three leading right-wing critics of the Jewish state, according to a new poll by a national GOP consulting firm.

Why it matters: The poll challenges the notion that Republican opinion toward Israel is fracturing significantly, and points to a potential disconnect between GOP voters’ attitudes and the sentiments of those who often draw the most attention online.


  • The survey, conducted by OnMessage Inc. for the Combat Antisemitism Movement‘s political arm, essentially provides a roadmap for pro-Israel Republicans’ messaging ahead of the 2028 presidential campaign.
  • It seeks to cast the right’s leading critics of Israel — Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens and Nick Fuentes — as liabilities in the GOP primary.

Zoom in: After the midterms, Vice President Vance called on the U.S. and the GOP to “change our relationship to Israel,” elevating the nations’ longtime partnership as a 2028 campaign issue at a time when Vance is eyeing a presidential bid.

  • Israel is supported by 68% of Republican voters in Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada and South Carolina, according to the survey, a result similar to findings by Gallup and Pew. 17% disfavored Israel.
  • 78% said the GOP’s “relationship with Israel” makes them more likely to vote Republican. Large majorities also agreed with pro-Israel messages.

In contrast, 53% of those surveyed said they disapprove of Carlson, and 30% approve. But among voters under 45 years old, Carlson’s approval/disproval ratings were tied at 46%.

  • 49% of the Republicans surveyed disapproved of Owens, while 23% approved.
  • Fuentes, the least-known of the three media figures, was viewed unfavorably by 25% and favored by 13%. Among self-described MAGA Republicans, 22% approved and 23% disapproved of him, however.
  • “The fringe messengers are underwater,” says a slide deck for the poll, which was conducted ahead of the Combat Antisemitism Movement’s national conference Thursday in Charleston, S.C.

Stunning stat: Vance is more popular in the GOP than President Trump.

  • 75% view Trump favorably and 23% disfavor him, a net of +52 points.
  • Vance: 80% favorable and 19% unfavorable, a net of +61.

The intrigue: Vance is friends with Carlson, whose son used to work in the vice president’s office. The two have resisted speaking ill of each other even as Carlson has grown more critical of the president and the war in Iran.

  • 46% of the GOP voters surveyed said a Carlson endorsement of a presidential candidate would make them less likely to support that person; 16% said it would make them more likely and 39% said it wouldn’t matter.

Yes, but: The poll is conducted for an advocacy group and seeks to provide messaging guidance for candidates and surrogates. So some of its questions are leading.

  • By 83%-5%, Republicans said they viewed Carlson less favorably when told “he endorsed Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, a radical Muslim socialist recently elected to the U.S. Senate in Michigan whose political associates include someone that said, ‘America deserved 9/11.’ “
  • The survey tested ways to attack Owens and Fuentes on the campaign trail by describing extreme comments from both and found that outsized majorities of Republican voters would call on a candidate to denounce them.
  • By 86%-7%, respondents agreed with the statement, “There is no place for antisemitism in the Republican Party.” And 66% said there’s no place in the party for antisemites, while 15% said they should be welcomed under a “big tent.”

What they’re saying: Fuentes declined to comment, Owens couldn’t be reached and Carlson questioned the financiers of the poll.

  • “The poll was commissioned by the ‘Combat Antisemitism Movement’? Seriously? Pretty funny. Where does their funding come from?” Carlson asked via text. (The donors are primarily Jewish and Zionist contributors, according to Influence Watch).
  • “If the point is to convince Republican candidates that American voters love [Israeli leader Benjamin] Netanyahu and want more wars for Israel, good luck in the next election,” he said. “It’s so absurd. But I’m sure you’ll have Republican senators waving around the poll results like they mean something.”
  • Former Virginia Attorney General Jason Miyares, a U.S. Advisory Board Member of the Combat Antisemitism Movement, dismissed the criticism: “For a Republican presidential candidate, standing up against antisemitism is not a political risk — it is the price of admission and good politics. Most importantly, it is simply the right thing to do.”

The poll of 1,000 respondents (250 from each of the four early states) was conducted Nov. 7-10. The margin of error: +/- 3.1%.

   

You don't have permission to register