Court Blocks New York’s Flawed Pied-à-Terre Tax Rollout
A Staten Island judge ordered New York City to halt its pied-à-terre tax rollout and redesign its implementation process. Justice Wayne Ozzi ruled that the city unlawfully forced homeowners to prove their residency status instead of verifying the information itself. The decision affects roughly 17,000 notices already sent and requires the city to take down an online tax roll covering 900,000 properties. The judge did not strike down the tax itself, and the city plans to appeal.
Separately, former Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross and casino mogul Steve Wynn filed suit Monday arguing the tax violates state and federal constitutions. They contend the levy discriminates against nonresidents who cannot vote against it and that lawmakers improperly labeled it a surcharge to bypass a 2.5 percent cap on property tax increases. Ross faces an $83,500 bill while Wynn owes roughly $183,000. Another group of homeowners filed a similar constitutional challenge Tuesday.
The tax applies to homes worth $5 million or more that do not serve as primary residences. The city sent 1,210 correction letters in August to owners wrongly identified in the initial rollout. Judge Ozzi’s order requires officials to use tax records and other data to make initial determinations and explain their reasoning in new notices.
Mayor Mamdani introduced the pied-à-terre tax to address budget shortfalls, intensifying his conflict with the city’s business and financial communities. The Real Estate Board of New York called the court ruling an important victory but noted legal challenges continue. Governor Hochul said the state is prepared to defend the tax, framing opponents as wealthy owners of multimillion-dollar second homes fighting against paying their share.
The post Court Blocks New York’s Flawed Pied-à-Terre Tax Rollout appeared first on Propmodo.
